Result card
|
Authors: Janek Saluse, Kristi Liiv, Raul-Allan Kiivet
Internal reviewers: Grace Jennings, Scott Goulden
The UK NHS AAA screening programme was started in 2009. Screening is carried out according to the pathway described in Figure 1. Considering medical practice and diagnostic criteria in Europe, it is likely that the screening pathway would be similar in other European countries if AAA screening were implemented.
Figure 1. Abdominal aortic aneurysm screening pathway in UK {1}
NHS guidelines for AAA screening {2} have identified 65-year-old men as the target population for AAA screening based on clinical studies. In the UK all men who are registered with a general practitioner (GP) will receive a personal invitation by mail for screening in the year that they turn 65. Men older than 65 can self-refer into the programme. Invitations are sent and feedback collected by local screening centres. Men who do not attend their screening invitation are either sent a second appointment or asked to contact their local programme to arrange a new date. Men who are invited a second time are sent a further letter saying they will not be invited for further appointments but can contact their local screening programme to self-refer for screening {2}.
Clinic locations are decided locally to ensure that they are accessible. Scanning typically takes place within community healthcare facilities such as community clinics, community hospitals, mobile units and primary care facilities. Men are seen by a health professional (sonographer or screening technician) on arrival at the clinic so that they can receive further information about screening before deciding whether to participate. Men are asked to give their consent to the screening procedure and the use of their personal information. Screeners record two anteroposterior (AP) measurements in centimetres of the maximum abdominal aortic diameter. Results are communicated immediately to all men verbally. Written results are also sent to GPs. Further investigations and treatment depend on the results of the scan:
In addition to follow-up scans, men are offered advice on how to reduce their cardiovascular risk factors. The man's GP may also be informed of the need to review medication and reassess blood pressure monitoring,
If the aorta cannot be visualised at the clinic a further scan appointment is arranged. If it cannot be visualised at the second appointment then the man is invited for a further scan at a hospital medical imaging unit. He is given guidance recommending minimum food and drink intake in the 4-h period before the proposed scan. Letters are also sent to GPs informing them of non-visualised screening results {2}.
Authors: Janek Saluse, Kristi Liiv, Raul-Allan Kiivet
Internal reviewers: Grace Jennings, Scott Goulden
The most significant impact of the screening programme will be on vascular surgery services and theatres. The number of elective operations will increase but there will be a decrease in the number of emergency operations over time {3}. A meta-analysis of four randomised controlled trials of screening older men for AAA was carried out by Lindholt and Norman (2008). A significant reduction in emergency operations (odds ratio=0.55; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.39-0.76) and an increase in elective operations (odds ratio=3.27; 95% CI 2.14-5.00) was found {4}.
As systematic population-based AAA screening has not been implemented in most European countries, the possible change after introducing the screening, can be estimated based on the number of elective and emergency operations at present. Mani et al. (2011) have analysed the statistics of AAA repair in several European countries. Table 1 shows the numbers of elective and emergency operations for Denmark, Norway and Sweden.
Table 1. Elective and emergency AAA operations in three European countries {5}
% of AAA repairs included |
Years included |
Number of elective operations |
Number of emergency operations |
% of emergency operations of total (95% CI) | |
Denmark |
99 |
2005-2009 |
2500 |
1026 |
29.1 (14.0-17.2) |
Norway |
93 |
2005-2008 |
2707 |
552 |
16.9 (15.6-18.2) |
Sweden |
93 |
2005-2009 |
4134 |
1517 |
26.8 (15.7-28.0) |
As a result of the increasing number of elective and the decreasing number of emergency operations after the introduction of AAA screening, the workload in involved hospital departments changes. According to The Scottish Government Health Improvement Strategy Division, patients who survive emergency repair of a ruptured AAA are admitted to the intensive treatment unit (ITU) and prolonged ITU admissions are common. After elective open AAA repair most patients in Scotland are admitted to the high dependency unit (HDU) rather than the ITU. After EVAR repair most patients are admitted to an HDU for one day but in some hospitals in Scotland patients are admitted to the vascular surgery ward after the procedure and do not occupy critical care beds {3}.
AAA screening is different from other screening programmes in that the mortality rates associated with treatment are significant: 3-5% for open surgery and 1-3% for EVAR {3}.
Therefore actual mortality is very dependent on the percentage of men that are treated with EVAR repairs. Also other risk factors like age and sex influence mortality. More detailed information about the percentage of EVAR procedures and the percentage of procedures done in women for Denmark, Norway and Sweden are presented in Table 2.
Table 2. Mean age, % of procedures in women and% of EVAR procedures for elective and emergency operations in three European countries (95% CI) {5}
Denmark |
Norway |
Sweden | ||
Elective | ||||
Mean age |
71.1 (70.8-71.4) |
72.2 (71.9-72.5) |
72.1 (71.9-72.3) | |
% of women |
17.2 (15.8-18.7) |
17.8 (16.4-19.3) |
18.4 (17.2-19.6) | |
% of EVAR |
23.8 (22.1-25.5) |
29.0 (27.2-30.9) |
43.9 (42.3-45.4) | |
Emergency | ||||
Mean age |
72.4 (72.0-72.9) |
72.3 (71.6-72.9) |
73.8 (72.3-74.2) | |
% of women |
13.3 (11.3-15.5) |
17.9 (15.0-21.4) |
19.6 (17.7-21.7) | |
% of EVAR |
0.6 (0.3-1.3) |
7.6 (5.4-10.5) |
15.2 (13.4-17.1) |
The Vascular Society of Great Britain and Ireland has issued a framework for improving the results of elective AAA repair. The aim of the framework is to halve the mortality rate for elective AAA surgery in the UK (to 3.5%) by 2014 {6}.
Preoperative:
{6}.
Operation:
Facilities:
Elective AAA repair should only be undertaken in hospitals where:
Also the Scottish AAA screening programme foresees a minimum of 20 elective surgeries per unit per year, rising over time to an estimated 32. Patients found to have an AAA should be referred to services that can undertake both open and endovascular repair of aneurysm and that offer advice to each patient on which procedure is most appropriate {3}. All referrals must be assessed for suitability for EVAR. It is estimated that 50% of screen-detected aneurysms in Scotland will be suitable for endovascular repair {3}.
There may be a small impact on Primary Care services from men requesting further information on the screening programme. Information on the screening programme will be circulated to Primary Care prior to roll out. GP practices will be notified of patients who are on surveillance or referred to vascular services {3}.
Authors: Janek Saluse, Kristi Liiv, Raul-Allan Kiivet
Internal reviewers: Grace Jennings, Scott Goulden
The difference in patients’ paths is that more men are referred for treatment before AAA rupture (which would send them directly to emergency departments).