Result card

  • ETH7: What are the benefits and harms for participants of the screening, and what is the balance between the benefits and harms when implementing and when not implementing Abdominal Aorta Aneurysm Screening ? Who will balance the risks and benefits in practice and how?
English
No adaptation help available for this domain

What are the benefits and harms for participants of the screening, and what is the balance between the benefits and harms when implementing and when not implementing Abdominal Aorta Aneurysm Screening ? Who will balance the risks and benefits in practice and how?

Authors: Gottfried Endel

Internal reviewers: Wilhelm Donner, Scott Goulden, Grace Jennings, Paolo Giorgi Rossi, Ingrid Wilbacher, Claudia Wild

In organised screening the final decision about participation remains at the individual level. The healthcare system and the care provider are responsible only for the best possible information to permit informed decision making or informed consent.

  • Respect for autonomy: organised population screening is recommended and provides information to support decision making on the individual level.
  • Non-maleficence: effects on other aspects of the healthcare system are important. Sustainability and resource use, in particular, may influence decisions at the system level.
  • Beneficence: balancing risks and cost with potential benefits can only be done at the local level (information on cost and organisational issues is local). A societal perspective – looking beyond the healthcare system perspective – is recommended.
  • Justice: In this question, the domain of justice requires objective information to compare the different possible ways of investing public money.

The main challenge of (most) political decisions in healthcare is the conflicting goals and values not only in different policy areas but also on different levels within the system. In a pluralistic society such conflicts are normal. Usually the level of clinical medicine “belongs”  to the patient and the clinician. The level of the health system is the domain of “organisations” – the stakeholders (providers, payers, patient groups, industry and so on). The last level deals with the balance of interests between political fields such as education, the labour market, others... and health. It may be attributable to the fact that the issue of AAA screening is a multi-level, multi-stakeholder and diverse interest dilemma. The international dimension should also be taken into account – particularly the previously mentioned open method of coordination of the EU.

So the balancing of the benefits and harms can be done only at the local level because local current use has to be taken into account. The open method of coordination aims to harmonise  healthcare and public health priorities on the EU level.

Important
Partially
Endel G Result Card ETH7 In: Endel G Ethical analysis In: Jefferson T, Vicari N, Frønsdal K [eds.]. Abdominal Aorta Aneurysm Screening [Core HTA], Agenzia nationale per i servizi sanitari regionali (age.na.s), Italy; 2013. [cited 28 May 2023]. Available from: http://corehta.info/ViewCover.aspx?id=106